
Before I write a blog post often times I'm 'thinking about writing it' for quite a while before. I've been thinking about writing a post on this topic for quite some time, and it really came to a head last Friday. As I'm thinking about a topic I will explore in my mind what I might say, the arguments I might make, and even the picture I want to go along with the posting.
As I have thought about this particular topic in the past I felt a number of conflicts, but I have resisted making a post about it before today. The reason I am writing now is that really there was just one specific event that made me want to set off on a rant.
When, in my minds eye, I tried to expand my concern into a more general area I kept realizing that I didn't actually have a larger complaint. It really just comes down to this specific incident which set me off. And, finally, I am not sure I should be talking publicly about this situation at all. Nevertheless, this evening, and perhaps against my better judgment, I want to take a few minutes to raise the issue and see what kind of feedback I get from the rest of my online brethren.
I have plenty of posts on this blog praising Freemasonry. I say all kinds of nice things about the Blue Lodge and why I enjoy being in it just so much. I needn't repeat any of that here. My general positive opinion of the institution has not really changed.
The issue I have, the thing that I don't 'like' about Freemasonry is that, at times, and to certain people, it can be full of self importance, inflated ego, and an over-indulgence of meaningless titles, honors, and awards.
Right off the bat I have to say that I see very little of this in the Blue Lodge. The highest rank you can have in your local Blue Lodge is Worshipful Master. And as much of a fuss as it seems we sometimes make of that, the reality is that you are only Worshipful Master for one year and you better not get too big for your britches because next year someone else has a turn.
So, if I'm not referring to the Blue Lodge, just who am I referring to? Well, I guess it would have to be the
appendant bodies?
Which ones might those be?
Well, likely candidates are The Shrine, Eastern Star, The York Rite, the Scottish Rite, the Grand Lodge, and
DeMolay.
You sure might think the Scottish Rite was a major culprit, what with titles like:
- 4° Master Traveler Secret Master
- 5° Perfect Master Perfect Master
- 6° Master of the Brazen Serpent Intimate Secretary
- 7° Provost and Judge Provost and Judge
- 8° Intendant of the Building Intendant of the Building
- 9° Master of the Temple Elu of the Nine
- 10° Master Elect Elu of the Fifteen
- 11° Sublime Master Elected Elu of the Twelve
- 12° Grand Master Architect Master Architect
- 13° Master of the Ninth Arch Royal Arch of Solomon
- 14° Grand Elect Mason Perfect Elu
- 15° Knight of the East or Sword Knight of the East, of the Sword, or of the Eagle
- 16° Prince of Jerusalem Prince of Jerusalem
- 17° Knight of the East and West Knight of the East and West
- 18° Knight of the Rose Croix de Knight Rose Croix Heredom Council of Kadosh
- 19° Grand Pontiff Grand Pontiff
- 20° Master ad Vitam Master of the Symbolic Lodge
- 21° Patriarch Noachite Noachite, or Prussian Knight
- 22° Prince of Libanus Knight of the Royal Axe, or Prince of Libanus
- 23° Chief of the Tabernacle Chief of the Tabernacle
- 24° Brother of the Forest Prince of the Tabernacle
- 25° Master of Achievement Knight of the Brazen Serpent
- 26° Friend and Brother Eternal Prince of Mercy, or Scottish Trinitarian
- 27° Knight of Jerusalem Knight Commander of the Temple
- 28° Knight of the Sun, or Prince Knight of the Sun, or Prince Adept Adept
- 29° Knight of St. Andrew Scottish Knight of Saint Andrew
- 30° Grand Inspector Knight Kadosh, or Knight of the White and Black Eagle
- 31° Knight Aspirant Inspector Inquisitor
- 32° Sublime Prince of the Royal Master of the Royal Secret Secret
These are some pretty gaudy titles. Where did they come from? My guess is that, at the time speculative Freemasonry was forming in Europe, it was quite the fad to give each other fancy sounding titles so as to either mock, or compete with, the titles conferred amongst the gentry.
As I read the writings from the 19
th century all I can guess is that back then people enjoyed creating fancy sounding degrees and titles to make themselves feel more important and give their ceremonies a
faux impression of preponderance and majesty.
You really have to wonder when, in an organization that espouses the importance of being 'on the level' with one another, that we have folded into its structure a wide array of titles and honors of individual distinction. Sometimes it seems we do just about everything but bow and scrape.
This all might sound rather pathetic and hopeless if it were not for one important fact. I know many, many, Freemasons. By now I know or have met most of the really active Freemasons in the entire state of Missouri.
I've met a number of Grand Masters and members of the Grand Lodge. Hundreds of past masters and 32
nd degree Masons. I know the members of the York Rite, the Shrine, Eastern Star, and count among my best friends those most exalted and rare 33rd degree Masons.
And, in all that time, I have found in them almost universally to be men of great humility and good cheer. I think it is interesting that we have what I believe is a very important
appendant body here in the Midwest which goes by the name of '
The Sword of Bunker Hill'. This particular order has, as a key component of its ceremony, of making the very strong point that no matter what your 'rank or privilege' you are just the same as any other brother in the lodge. This degree will teach you humility one way or the other, or you won't survive the ceremony itself intact.
As I began to contemplate this issue of pompous sounding titles, degrees, and honors I soon came to realize that I know of virtually no Brother, no matter how high or low in station, who actually seems to make much of an issue of it. In fact, I have met almost universally brothers who were kind, humble, caring, sharing, and open with every other person they met.
So, maybe there are a handful of individuals who actually care about these silly titles and make an issue out of them. Maybe it is a problem, but one that is really more about public relations with the rest of the world than anything else.
In the end, maybe my issue is not with these ridiculous titles and ceremonies. Maybe my issue is with just a handful of specific men who have abused this situation? And, sure enough, I
think that is the case.
I thought long and hard about whether I would share the following in public, but I have now decided that I will and let the chips fall where they may.
Earlier this year a Brother who I deeply respect, nominated me for a 'high honor' in Freemasonry. I didn't ask him to do so and I didn't expect it to happen. I certainly don't know whether or not I deserved this 'honor' anyway. And, to be frank, I really didn't (and still don't) care. However, I accepted it out of respect for my Brother who nominated me. And, I'm afraid, I might be showing a little bit of disrespect right now by writing this post. Let me be clear, my problem is not with my dear friend who nominated me. The issue I have will be made clear in a moment.
I was given notice that I was to receive this high honor. This notice was accompanied with pamphlets explaining just how truly earth shattering it was that I was going to be honored with this grand title. It also came with a ring sizer so I could select the special ring I could wear to show the world my esteemed and vaunted position. I was informed that I would need to wear a tuxedo to this auspicious event.
I dutifully showed up for the ceremony. I was taken into a room with the group of men who were also being honored that evening. We had to swear a super-duper-top-secret-don't tell anyone ever in the world oath. The super secret oath was basically devoid of content and there was nothing in it that could ever be considered truly 'secret' by anyone. In fact, the single and only reason that the oath was 'secret' was to further create the aura and mystery that we were acquiring some truly great honor in the ceremony.
To be frank, the entire situation seemed like little boys creating secret oaths to get into their own little private club-house. In fact, as you will find out in a moment, it pretty much was just like that.
Seriously, who in the world gives a rats ass that any of we Freemasons have any title or honor within the organization? Who cares!? Absolutely no one outside of Freemasonry and, as I pointed out earlier, I don't think many of us inside of Freemasonry really care all that much either.
Pretending to be a big fish in a very, very, tiny pond is all a bit absurd if you ask me.
As the ceremony commenced (which in total took well over three hours) we were serenaded with speeches and heralds about just what a mind blowing thing it was for us to receive this great honor.
In the end, we were each literally 'knighted' with a sword by a smiling chieftain proud to have us join his little club. We were also informed that the 'honor' came along with it an annual commitment to pay dues to *yet one more* organization!
Once we had received our knighthood, next the men who had performed the ceremony had to pat each other on the back and give each other meaningless plaques for another hour.
This entire ceremony reached levels of absurdity such that I could barely manage to stand there with a polite smile on my face the whole time.
Maybe by now, if you actually read this far, you are wondering why I have such a bug up my butt about something that is clearly fairly harmless, trivial, and pointless.
Well, here is why. The award I was given was the
DeMolay Legion of Honor.
This is an honor conferred in an organization dedicated to helping young men.I kid you not!
DeMolay is an organization for young men between the ages of 12 and 21. In general it is an exceptional organization. I am currently the chairman of a
DeMolay chapter and I have been involved in the organization for about the past six years. I have seen this organization do a lot of great things for these young men. It can be truly
transformative and a powerful force to help young men strive to become better adults.
Our chapter has, in many ways, acted as a kind of 'Big Brothers' program and we have helped a lot of young men who came from difficult backgrounds. Within
DeMolay they were able to be influenced by men of great character and engage in activities that they would never have been able to do any other way.
While I am very proud of
DeMolay and the young men in it. I am seriously, seriously, seriously, annoyed at the leadership giving out freaking nonsense awards to ADULTS!!!!!!!!!!!!
DeMolay is for and about the young men. I do not need a 'legion of honor'. I do not need awards, accolades, or anything else. My reward is when I see one of our young men who, at one time, was headed on a bad path, turn their lives around and go to college, or enlist in the National Guard.
This entire scene of the adult leadership knighting one another, handing out plaques to one another, patting one another on the back, and telling each other just how great they are was, to be frank, almost sickening to me.
These are some very big fish in an absurdly small pond. I believe they honestly need to rethink what this is all about. I do not want to see us hand out one more award, bestow one more absurd title, or waste one more minute of our youths time with these absolutely ridiculous and idiotic banquets and awards for adult leadership. (And, yes, there were a whole bunch of young men who had to sit through this nonsense.)
If you want to give out an award to an adult leader, how about just shaking their hand and saying thanks, "good job brother."
That's all the award any of us should expect or seek.
Ok, what started out as a mild post has ended in a rant. I'm glad I got it off of my chest. I have spent six years sitting through untold and ungodly hours of banquets and ceremonies watching the adult leadership in
DeMolay prance around in tuxedos, weighted around their necks with medals, chains, emblems, and jewels. I'm sick of seeing it and I think it needs to stop.
Give out awards to the kids. Give out trophies to the kids. Do whatever you can do for the kids. But, for all that is holy in the world, stop giving yourself awards, titles, honors, medals, jewels, and ceremonies. Just stop it already.
What do you think? Do Freemasons pat each other on the back too much? Do we spend too much time giving each other medals, awards, jewels, honors and ceremonies? Is that what 'making good men better' is really supposed to be all about?
Is this just my pet-peeve or is it yours too?